I think Kawhi is too low. I know he’s had some bad injury years recently, but at his healthiest, he was extremely hard to stop, and his 2019 run was legendary.
He should unquestionably be higher than KD and DWade.
Yes but only because Garnett should not be 6.
I’d say it’s about right. And I think Luka will be top 5 by the time he’s done.
Yes he should be above Wade and Garnett. There are a couple more that are somewhat arguable (Durant, Jokic) though I probably agree with their placement and probably one below that you can argue should be above Dirk (Giannis)
Im fine with Durant’s placement but Wade at 8 is questionable
Crazy that Luca is allready on the list 🤯
I’d argue ahead of Wade and Garnett. Theres no real argument to put him ahead of anyone else from a neutral fans perspective, I think.
Garnett was great, but him being ahead of Durant and Jokic is insanity.
Tim Duncan should be Top 3. Personally I’d put him 2 because I’d only take LeBron and Jordan ahead of him to build a franchise from all the players I’ve seen. He is the ultimate “winning player”.
This a troll list they tried sliding Draymond in there and left out Dwight
Draymond Green at 22? Duncan only at 4? No Kyrie? Yeah fuck this list
Yes and no.
I think hes sitting in a good spot, but KG at 6 is crazy work. I get it, I get it, he won DPOY and was a considerably better defender than Dirk.
Despite that, in no universe would KG have ever taken us to the heights Dirk did. KG could get you 20/10 pretty consistently but he couldn’t take over a game and he damn sure wasn’t about to pop you for 40+. Dirk played 60 more games than KG, yet scored 5k more points.
Dirk was asked to be the focal point and to carry a team over and over. KG couldn’t do that; he needed Pierce and Allen to change his legacy.
Despite that, I think 10 is a good spot for Dirk. I just disagree with KG at 6.
KG at 6 and Dirk at 10 is disrespectful af. GTFO with that bs.
KG at 6 is objectively dumb.
Dirk and KD should be over DWade and Garnett.
You could tell the list was cooked when they had Curry ahead of Duncan.
To me Garnett is always way overated on these lists. TBH he was the 2nd and sometimes 3rd option on his championship team.
Paul Pierce was the real #1 on Boston IMO, then you also had Ray Allen and Rajon.
Dirk was unequivically the best player on the Mavs (his entire career) and arguably the entire league on the 2011 run.
No but KG should be lower too
That’s a troll account
Little bitch wade won’t be on any respectable lists
Wade and Garnett should be under Dirk…. I said what I said
I think Melo should be on that list.
Either that or Dwadde should be lower
Over Wade Garnett and jokic yes
Yes, he should be ahead of Wade and Garnett. Having Garnett ahead of Jokic and Giannis is a bad joke, as is Kobe over Shaq and Duncan. Wade over Nash, Giannis, Luka and several others is plain ridiculous. Don’t even get me started on Green over Luka and Westbrook. It seems like whoever made the list just wrote down the names of players who made all-nba at some time in a random order.
Garnett, Wade and KD over Dirk are questionable. Jok shows greatness that will most likely eclipse most people on this list by the time he’s done. Top 5 are probably untouchable.
Dirk should be 6.
I don’t agree, but an OK with everything to 8. Slide Dwade back – DRose was a top tier player as long as Wade and he’s nowhere to be seen. Just not enough longevity at his peak as a #1 guy. JKidd’s ring gets him ahead of Paul that’s fine. Green over Westbrook is wild. I don’t like Russ but he’s better than Manu right? I wonder how close Dwight’s peak got him to this list.
He should be at 6 or at 7 behind Jokic
I will fight to death that Dirk is better than Kevin Garnett. Could also argue Dirk over Wade, so he could potentially be bumped up 2 spots
Luka at 25 though going to be higher after he gets that ring next year
I’ve always had him above wade, but understand why he rarely gets put above wade outside of dallas.
People are mentioning KG so I’ll comment on him: Garnett was soo soo good on both ends. Clearly dirk better offensively but KG was absolutely dominant for a decade.
The only other issue i have with this list Jokic. I cant put him above dirk yet. But hes gonna be there soon.
I’d be hard pressed to put him higher than anyone else in the top 10, but aint nothing wrong with top 10.
Where the fuck is Jokic
Oh nvm I see haha
Wade, KG and Durant needed super teams to win, so all below Dirk.
35 comments
I think Kawhi is too low. I know he’s had some bad injury years recently, but at his healthiest, he was extremely hard to stop, and his 2019 run was legendary.
He should unquestionably be higher than KD and DWade.
Yes but only because Garnett should not be 6.
I’d say it’s about right. And I think Luka will be top 5 by the time he’s done.
Yes he should be above Wade and Garnett. There are a couple more that are somewhat arguable (Durant, Jokic) though I probably agree with their placement and probably one below that you can argue should be above Dirk (Giannis)
Im fine with Durant’s placement but Wade at 8 is questionable
Crazy that Luca is allready on the list 🤯
I’d argue ahead of Wade and Garnett. Theres no real argument to put him ahead of anyone else from a neutral fans perspective, I think.
Garnett was great, but him being ahead of Durant and Jokic is insanity.
Tim Duncan should be Top 3. Personally I’d put him 2 because I’d only take LeBron and Jordan ahead of him to build a franchise from all the players I’ve seen. He is the ultimate “winning player”.
This a troll list they tried sliding Draymond in there and left out Dwight
Draymond Green at 22? Duncan only at 4? No Kyrie? Yeah fuck this list
Yes and no.
I think hes sitting in a good spot, but KG at 6 is crazy work. I get it, I get it, he won DPOY and was a considerably better defender than Dirk.
Despite that, in no universe would KG have ever taken us to the heights Dirk did. KG could get you 20/10 pretty consistently but he couldn’t take over a game and he damn sure wasn’t about to pop you for 40+. Dirk played 60 more games than KG, yet scored 5k more points.
Dirk was asked to be the focal point and to carry a team over and over. KG couldn’t do that; he needed Pierce and Allen to change his legacy.
Despite that, I think 10 is a good spot for Dirk. I just disagree with KG at 6.
KG at 6 and Dirk at 10 is disrespectful af. GTFO with that bs.
KG at 6 is objectively dumb.
Dirk and KD should be over DWade and Garnett.
You could tell the list was cooked when they had Curry ahead of Duncan.
To me Garnett is always way overated on these lists. TBH he was the 2nd and sometimes 3rd option on his championship team.
Paul Pierce was the real #1 on Boston IMO, then you also had Ray Allen and Rajon.
Dirk was unequivically the best player on the Mavs (his entire career) and arguably the entire league on the 2011 run.
No but KG should be lower too
That’s a troll account
Little bitch wade won’t be on any respectable lists
In my opinion the top 11 should have been;
1. LeBron
2. Duncan
3. Kobe
4. Curry
5. Shaq
6. Jokic
7. KD
8. Giannis
9. Dirk
10. KG
11. DWade
Also, if Luka wins a championship next season how far does he jump up this list? I can see him jump up 5-10 spots.
This is a joke list, designed to piss people off and get clicks. Do not fall for it or engage!
I think wade and kg are a bit high
Dirk is above Wade and Garnett. Duncan should be above Curry and Kobe. Other than that the rankings are fine
Actual Top 10 imo
1. LeBron
2. Duncan
3. Kobe
4. Curry
5. Shaq
6. Jokić
7. Durant
8. Dirk
9. Garnett
10. Wade
Wade and Garnett should be under Dirk…. I said what I said
I think Melo should be on that list.
Either that or Dwadde should be lower
Over Wade Garnett and jokic yes
Yes, he should be ahead of Wade and Garnett. Having Garnett ahead of Jokic and Giannis is a bad joke, as is Kobe over Shaq and Duncan. Wade over Nash, Giannis, Luka and several others is plain ridiculous. Don’t even get me started on Green over Luka and Westbrook. It seems like whoever made the list just wrote down the names of players who made all-nba at some time in a random order.
Garnett, Wade and KD over Dirk are questionable. Jok shows greatness that will most likely eclipse most people on this list by the time he’s done. Top 5 are probably untouchable.
Dirk should be 6.
I don’t agree, but an OK with everything to 8. Slide Dwade back – DRose was a top tier player as long as Wade and he’s nowhere to be seen. Just not enough longevity at his peak as a #1 guy. JKidd’s ring gets him ahead of Paul that’s fine. Green over Westbrook is wild. I don’t like Russ but he’s better than Manu right? I wonder how close Dwight’s peak got him to this list.
He should be at 6 or at 7 behind Jokic
I will fight to death that Dirk is better than Kevin Garnett. Could also argue Dirk over Wade, so he could potentially be bumped up 2 spots
Luka at 25 though going to be higher after he gets that ring next year
I’ve always had him above wade, but understand why he rarely gets put above wade outside of dallas.
People are mentioning KG so I’ll comment on him: Garnett was soo soo good on both ends. Clearly dirk better offensively but KG was absolutely dominant for a decade.
The only other issue i have with this list Jokic. I cant put him above dirk yet. But hes gonna be there soon.
I’d be hard pressed to put him higher than anyone else in the top 10, but aint nothing wrong with top 10.
Where the fuck is Jokic
Oh nvm I see haha
Wade, KG and Durant needed super teams to win, so all below Dirk.