Tyson Barrie voted most overrated in Avs History. Next up, Who is the best Av ever?

48 comments

1. Joe Sakic

2. Has to be Sakic.

3. Healthy Peter Forsberg

4. Super Joe edges Nate the Great (for now)

   https://stathead.com/hockey/versus-finder.cgi?player_id2=sakicjo01&player_id1=mackina01&request=1&utm_campaign=2023_01_wdgt_player_comparison&utm_source=hr&utm_medium=sr_xsite&utm_id=mackina01

5. It’s Sakic, but MacK could get there.

6. Can we just put in Sakic and skip the vote? Absolutely no disrespect to any of the other amazing Avs we’ve had, but the way things currently stand this is a no brainer.

7. If not Sakic, it has to be Forsberg, maybe McKinnon

8. Joe.

   That isn’t even a serious question.

9. It’s Joe Sakic.

10. Peter The Great. Top 5 all time player IMO with a shortened career by injures

11. Foppa

12. Super Joe

13. Sakic. Roy and Forsberg are right there, but Joe is the guy.

14. As much as Peter was absolutely incredible, Joe wins this. If Peter had a longer career I’d say yes but I just can’t. My vote is Joe.

15. Peter Forsberg

16. Joe Sakic.

17. Sakic easy. If you think otherwise… You’re wrong

18. Joe “You don’t get to talk to Mr.” Sakic

19. Sakic

20. Sakic. Goodbye the end.

21. Man, feels like Morris, Selanne and Jost would have been more deserving but I guess that’s what happens when you split the vote. A bit of disrespect for Barrie there.

    Anyway of course this answer is Sakic

22. Might be a bit early to call it but I’m gonna have to go with Cale🥬

23. Super Joe

24. Super Joe then Mac

25. A no brainer!

    Howler!

26. Roy.

27. Sakic by a county mile (respectfully)

28. Sakic

29. It’s Sakic. But Foppa had the higher ceiling and I was always on the edge of my seat when he was on the ice. I gotta give an honorable mention shout out to Goulet and the OG “Peter the Great”/Stosh, both incredible players in the QC days of the franchise. I still think 16 and 26 should be up in the rafters.

30. My brain says Sakic but my heart says Foppa.

31. Sakic,

    Nate and Cale can take the crown from him depending on how their careers play out.

32. Sakic, then MacKinnon, then Foppa, then Roy

33. Joe Sakic — it’s not even a competition. Great on the ice and in the office.

34. Definitely Joe Sakic. Close second would be Patrick Roy. Honorable mention: Adam Foote.

35. Joe

36. Sakic. But Forsberg is my all time favorite

37. Greg Zanon

38. An argument could be made for Peter Forsberg, but it’s definitely Joe Sakic.

39. Sakic made me an Avs fan when I was a kid. He was one of the longest tenured captains in history, is top 10 in points all-time, was respected even by the teams greatest rivals and will forever be remembered who gave Bourque the first cup lift of his career.

    Oh also he built a cup team as a manager.

    No question.

40. Peter Forsberg. Followed closely by Joe Sakic and Nathan MacKinnon.

41. I’ll say it, Dermy

42. Super Joe Sakic

43. There is a reason why the other team would put out their shutdown line against Forsberg. The reason is because he was freaking the most talented player on the team. I don’t care about longevity when he still had a HOF career. Best player is best player and that’s Forsberg.

44. there is no other answer here besides Burnaby Joe

45. Sakic is probably the most **important**, but Forsberg was the **best**

46. How is Tyson Barrie the most over rated? And best would have to be between Sakic and MacKinnon, you literally would not be wrong if you chose one over the other. You choose Samic over Mack? You are 100% correct. You choose Mack over Sakic, you are 100% correct. I would lean towards Sakic, though, just because he has the two cups as a player AND the cup as the GM.

47. Tyson Barrie most overrated?! Whaaat. No way.

    Also, Sakic obviously.

48. Sakic. I wish it was mack, but it’s definitely the sak .