Joe Flacco’s no Joe Montana or Tom Brady, but he’s had a good career, winning a Super Bowl MVP and a Comeback Player of the Year Award. Do you think he’ll make the Hall of Fame?
November 9, 2024
Joe Flacco’s no Joe Montana or Tom Brady, but he’s had a good career, winning a Super Bowl MVP and a Comeback Player of the Year Award. Do you think he’ll make the Hall of Fame?
10 comments
No his stats are mid
Do I think he is better than some current HOF QBs? Yes. Do I think he will be enshrined in Canton? No.
If he somehow led this Colts team to a Super Bowl victory? Maybe. As it stands now? No.
If he leads us to a Super Bowl, sure.
Otherwise it’s a tossup.
No. Eli Manning is a borderline case and he has 2 rings.
No. It’s the equivalent of putting Phil Simms or Jim Plunkett in the Hall.
No, he had one elite postseason in that SB run, but outside of that he was never “feared” by opposing teams/fanbases.
Great QB? Yes. Am I happy to see he is still slinging it? Yes. But he’s not going to the hall.
I hope he makes the bench this weekend.
Not at all. There are already too many players getting in the Hall. Memorabilia from Flacco’s 2012 run to the Super Bowl should be displayed in the Hall. (Maybe it already is)
No. He was never in the elite category of QBs. He was always in that Kirk Cousins level good, not great tier, where if you had a great roster (which the Ravens typically did), he could do enough to win and not hold the team back, and that was at his best. Now, he should be a backup, and I’m confused as to why the Colts are starting him, as most of you seem to be as well.
10 comments
No his stats are mid
Do I think he is better than some current HOF QBs? Yes. Do I think he will be enshrined in Canton? No.
If he somehow led this Colts team to a Super Bowl victory? Maybe. As it stands now? No.
If he leads us to a Super Bowl, sure.
Otherwise it’s a tossup.
No. Eli Manning is a borderline case and he has 2 rings.
No. It’s the equivalent of putting Phil Simms or Jim Plunkett in the Hall.
No, he had one elite postseason in that SB run, but outside of that he was never “feared” by opposing teams/fanbases.
Great QB? Yes. Am I happy to see he is still slinging it? Yes. But he’s not going to the hall.
I hope he makes the bench this weekend.
Not at all. There are already too many players getting in the Hall. Memorabilia from Flacco’s 2012 run to the Super Bowl should be displayed in the Hall. (Maybe it already is)
No. He was never in the elite category of QBs. He was always in that Kirk Cousins level good, not great tier, where if you had a great roster (which the Ravens typically did), he could do enough to win and not hold the team back, and that was at his best. Now, he should be a backup, and I’m confused as to why the Colts are starting him, as most of you seem to be as well.