Can #Seahawks win a Super Bowl with Geno Smith at QB?

26 comments

1. For half of his career, Russ didn't have an O line either and found a way to pull out the W in the second half. Geno is a good QB that is not mentally tough enough to make consistently good decisions when it matters. Even if you gave him an O line, inevitably he'll make more bad decisions that outweigh the good ones. I've seen enough.

2. Just STOP! Every excuse for such a mid QB.

3. Hahaha

4. I liked the Seahawks enough to put $200 on them to win the Super Bowl, but didn’t like them enough to put an extra $800 on them win it all.

5. I love how many experts who watch film and break it down and say Geno is a baller, then you get comments full of people who think they know ball, hating on Geno it’s embarrassing. Geno is awesome.

6. When the question be more, can we win a Super Bowl with our garbage offensive line?

7. Seriously!!

8. 103 yard pick 6 on a ball that he never should have thrown. 14 point swing. Geno will never win a superbowl as a QB 1

9. CAN ANY QUARTERBACK WIN. A SUPERBOWL IN SEATTLE WITH THIS FECES OFFENSIVE LINE ASSEMNBLED BY
   SEAHAWKS GENERAL MANAGER JOHN SCHNEIDER?

10. This a joke, right? 🤣🤣🤣 Geno is trash. Start Howell instead.

11. We need to draft a quarterback with talent and tremendous accuracy.

12. The fact is, no quarter back behind this line could win a super bowl, so it's really a pointless conversation. Geno is good enough in the right situation.

13. Easily, but not how this team is right now. No QB could.

    I did some research to compare what Wilson had in 2013 to what Geno has today.

    2013
    Offense
    26th ranked passing offense with 202.3 yards/games
    4th ranked rushing offense with 136.8 yards/game
    9th with 26.1 points/game
    Russell Wilson was ranked 22nd with 25.4 pass attempts/game
    2013
    Defense
    #1 Ranked by far with 273.6 yards/game
    #1 14.4 points/game

    2024 with Geno Smith
    28th ranked rushing attack with 91.2 yards/game
    #1 Ranked passing with 268.2 yards/game
    #1 at 38 pass attempts/game
    #14 ranked scoring offense with 23.3 points/game
    Geno is actually keeping us afloat right now.

14. Only with more pass protection for Geno and enough run block for K9 to have consistency. With time to work and a viable run game Geno can open up the playbook and expand the Seahawk's offense. As it is now with a bottom of the league level OL, Seahawks aren't even sniffing the playoffs.

15. Yeah we can we need a scoring Defense preferably grabbing Deone Walker or Mykel Williams or both if we can trade 2026 1st pick

16. Tell the truth brother, this man just told you. Fans that knows nothing about football. The truth about Geno outstanding. When Geno goes, the seahawks will be dead.
    With no quarterback.
    Be careful what you ask for.

17. If Seattle had a top-level offensive line, he definitely could win a Superbowl. He has no time for routes to develop which messes up the timing of the plays. Until Seattle fixes the offensive line problem, they will continue to flounder around and disappoint their fans.

18. Super Bowl?! Can't even win the division.

19. This is why I have never heard of Trevor Sikkema and perhaps I never will. Seahawks cannot win a Super Bowl with Geno Smith. It has to be Warren Moon, Matt Hasselback and Russell Wilson in their career primes by reflecting the history. Just simply putting, Geno takes too much to take and Geno takes such perfection to get to the Super Bowl. Just throwing dimes here and there will not get you to the Super Bowl. That will not simply ever happen in Seahawks future. But there's a guy sitting right behind Geno who can pull this out. His name is Sam Howell. This guy is as accurate (true quarterback) as Warren Moon. This guy will make everybody around better (Intangibles) like Matt Hasselbeck. This guy is as genius (game manager) as Russell Wilson on the field. If you simply give Sam Howell a chance, he will prove it.

20. You can really tell who knows football and who doesn’t by their view on geno smith lol

21. The Seahawks cannot win a super bowl with this offensive line. They need draft picks and they need to go into free agency to fix the offensive line .

22. Geno is the man! Finish the story Geno!

23. Yes. Geno isn't the problem.

24. Miss playoffs, macdonald would be in hot seat in a few years when the trend of losing continues.

25. Just take a look at Geno Smith's record verses the 49ers. After the bye it's going to get even worse. Why would you play someone who has no chance of winning the divisional championship? You know the ceiling with Geno Smith, but Sam Howell has tons of potential worth finding out about. I guess once the playoffs are off the table, they will finally concede the fact we were right all along and it was a big waste of cap and the Seahawks lost some valuable players because of it.

26. He absolutely can win a super bowl just not for Seattle because they have no line Jarred Goff with Detroit is a perfect example of how it can work with protection