Last day of the grid! Shoutout to Jordy, LeRoy and Driver, who made it a close race yesterday. Who is getting the top spot?

34 comments

1. Charles Woodson. He’s the best to come in and leave as a goat

   Edit: or Reggie white. Both are goated. I give it to Charles cuz he played more years

2. Charles Woodson

   Edit for accolades:
   Only defensive Heisman EVER. Defensive rookie of the year in 1998. First team All Pro 2nd and 3rd year in NFL. All Pro in 2009 and 2011. Interception leader in 2009 and 2011. Super Bowl in 2011.

3. Reggie White

4. Reggie White

5. Toss-up between the minister of defense and Charles Woodson

6. Don Hutson. Was the best end/receiver in football from his rookie season to his retirement.

7. I dont agree with Wood – as his last season as a Safety was anything but. He would have fit great in place of Mathews to me.

   Wild card – Marcedes Lewis since u/spooneybarger69 already picked the correct pick.

8. Don Hutson.

9. Hutson.

10. Charles woodson

11. Anyone else just upvoting this whole thread? 👀👀

12. Reggie White

13. Don Hutson

14. Aaron Rodgers

15. Nick Collins

16. Don Hutson or Sterling Sharpe for me. They were always packers. Reggie and Charles weren’t even tho I like both of those guys and they were huge parts of our success.

17. Fingers crossed for Evan Williams and Edgerrin Cooper.

18. Jay Cutler

19. Reggie

20. Don Hutson, the OG Wide Receiver. 3 time NFL champ, 2 time MVP, and just a ton of accolades.

    Still holds the record for highest career average TDs per game of any WR.

21. Brett Favre

22. How are more people not saying Aaron Rodgers? Pro Bowl year 2. Super Bowl year 3. MVP year 4. And had three straight 13 win season and 2 MVPs towards the end. Surefire first ballot hall of fame and arguably one of the, if not the greatest, QB of all time. Started great, ended great, in every sense of the definition.

23. I mean it’s a cop out pick but Rodgers started great and ended great through for 4000yd 24td and 12int his first starting season

24. Favre.

    Came in and led a comeback his first game. His career as a Packer ended in the NFC Championship with an MVP-caliber season.

    The atrium and all the stadium/franchise upgrades can be attributed to him and what he meant to the organization and the city.

25. Don Hutson. No contest imo.

26. Don Hutson. He was putting up Randy Moss numbers in the 1940’s.

27. Mason Crosby – selected sixth round of the draft in 2007 and was reliable as fuck. Even his last two years when he had some questionable kicks (largely because of age and the NFL changing kicking) he still nailed so many for us.

    Given what happened with kickers after he left, I don’t know how you couldn’t consider his last season great too. It only wasn’t great by HIS incredible standards that were set over years of consistent, thrilling play.

    I mean, there’s a reason he’s the all time leading scorer 🤣

28. Reggie “Charles” Hutson is the answer

29. Aaron Rodgers. Started with an early Super Bowl. Left with back to back MVPs

30. I know he’s not popular anymore, but Brett Favre. Took the Packers to the playoffs in 1993 and won 3 MVPs from 95-97 and won Super Bowl XXXI. He had one of his best statistical years in 2007 (his last Green Bay season) and played well in Minnesota.

31. Huston, Reggie, or Woodson.

32. Favre

33. OP- would you be able to post the top comments for each of these after the grid is updated? Be cool to see the reasoning, etc. behind some of these.

34. Don Hutson 

    There are a small handful of players who revolutionized their sport.  Hutson was one of those few.