Giants Grid Day 8: Who started okay and ended great?
November 14, 2024
This was basically a two-man race between Eli Manning and Tiki Barber, but Eli is the choice of Giants who started bad and ended great; you don't get much greater than a pair of Super Bowl MVPs. Only two to go!
Reminder that I will not be accepting Giants currently on the team.
12 comments
I would’ve picked Eli for today, but I’ll go Strahan.
I would have picked Tiki for the prior category so since he didn’t win I’m going with Tiki on the one.
Honorable Mention I would pick Phil Simms.
Strahan seems like the best choice
Phil Simms.
Got 2nd place in ROY voting and was leading the Giants to a winning record before the spate of injuries.
Became the Super Bowl MVP and set the completion % record.
Strahan
Chase “Hold my beer” Blackburn
Chris Snee
Toomer would be a good pick here.. set punting return records his first yr then turned into our leader in 2007 SB
Justin Tuck or Osi
Eli started bad and ended bad
Justin Tuck. Not to be confused with non-Giant Justin Tuck*er*
12 comments
I would’ve picked Eli for today, but I’ll go Strahan.
I would have picked Tiki for the prior category so since he didn’t win I’m going with Tiki on the one.
Honorable Mention I would pick Phil Simms.
Strahan seems like the best choice
Phil Simms.
Got 2nd place in ROY voting and was leading the Giants to a winning record before the spate of injuries.
Became the Super Bowl MVP and set the completion % record.
Strahan
Chase “Hold my beer” Blackburn
Chris Snee
Toomer would be a good pick here.. set punting return records his first yr then turned into our leader in 2007 SB
Justin Tuck or Osi
Eli started bad and ended bad
Justin Tuck. Not to be confused with non-Giant Justin Tuck*er*
David Tyree?