This was basically a two-man race between Eli Manning and Tiki Barber, but Eli is the choice of Giants who started bad and ended great; you don't get much greater than a pair of Super Bowl MVPs. Only two to go!

Reminder that I will not be accepting Giants currently on the team.

12 comments
  1. I would have picked Tiki for the prior category so since he didn’t win I’m going with Tiki on the one.

    Honorable Mention I would pick Phil Simms.

  2. Phil Simms.

    Got 2nd place in ROY voting and was leading the Giants to a winning record before the spate of injuries.

    Became the Super Bowl MVP and set the completion % record.

  3. Toomer would be a good pick here.. set punting return records his first yr then turned into our leader in 2007 SB

Leave a Reply