Wait, people wanna wait? Nah. I’d sooner trade our whole draft for Sam Darnold than just stick with Daniel Jones and not draft a QB
Sanders seems unreliable and Manning can’t come out yet.
1. Tank for the top pick
2. Trade that pick for a combo of picks and any established O-line or D-backs you can get.
3. Use whatever picks we do have on as many WR as possible.
4. Cut DJ loose.
5. Sign veteran QB to “prove it” deal.
6. Fire Schoen, keep Daboll (for now).
7. Begin rebuild, aim to have QB of the future in the next 2-3 years using pick or picks acquired in the (hypothetical #1 trade) or future picks.
8. Settle in, trust the process.
Edit: downvotes coming in from people who want us to waste a high pick on a mediocre QB prospect or the people who just wanna be able to say, “Tommy Cutlets!”
Yes let’s force a qb because it can’t possibly be worse…says every brain dead fan.
So you want to draft a QB, regardless if you think that QB is good or not? FWIW Ward and Sanders are the only prospects that might be worthy of a 1st round grade imo and personally I still want to see some more film out of them before I even feel comfortable saying that.
would you rather have penix or nabers?
if there isn’t a good qb prospect at whatever pick we have, don’t settle. i’d rather continue with a bridge qb until there’s a true qb 1 than settle with a good prospect and invest another 4 years of hope into it
What’s everyone’s obsession with Arch? He hasn’t done anything impressive in college yet. Everyone wants to wait another year for him but has he done anything to make us feel this way? Only good games have been against Mississippi St and…UTSA?? Don’t care what his name is, I’m not gonna pass on a player like Cam Ward and wait another year for a QB who hasn’t shown anything yet.
Nah let’s get Travis hunter and roll with jones for 8 more years.
Take a shot this year and if they fail take another shot next year. The giants burn first round picks all the time not any different if we do it with a qb
For the love of shit, did you guys not learn a fucking thing from Gettleman drafting Jones!? In 2018, Gettleman passed on a QB because he believed Eli still had it. When it became clear that Eli didn’t have it, Gettleman panicked and forced a QB pick (Jones), especially after the QB he wanted (Herbert) went back to school. This was a mistake that Schoen didn’t make last year. He tried to trade up for Maye, didn’t get him, and didn’t panic and took BPA.
How does anyone disagree with this? Sometimes I think Giants fans just want to be miserable
The Cardinals drafted Josh Rosen, found out he was shit, and didn’t hesitate to draft Kyler Murray the very next year. The Giants can’t get any worse from drafting Cam Ward, Shadeur, or whomever
Such a dumb take. Drafting a qb doesn’t mean we get a good qb. Not a sure thing bub
People also don’t realize Daboll doesn’t get to wait until the perfect draft to pick his GUY until he can be EVALUATED. This is the nfl, you take what you’re given or you sign someone. You can’t go 2-8 every year and blame it on not having your first choice of QB. This isn’t the local YMCA team.
If we draft a bust QB this year well guess what, we’ll probably be in a position to draft a new one next year and/or in 2027. Same thing the Cardinals did with Rosen. We just hung onto DJ for way too long that’s all
It’s crazy to me people don’t realize that Daboll will be on the last year of his contract and he’ll be trying to keep his job. There are morons in here thinking that he and Schoen will pass on a chance to develop their own QB??? They’re drafting a QB. Get over it.
Jones was projected in the 2nd round!!! It’s not the same.
If they hate this year’s crop, get a stopgap QB in free agency, and then trade back for more assets next year so they can get their guy, if he’s there.
18 comments
As much as I like Travis, QB is the way to go.
Wait, people wanna wait? Nah. I’d sooner trade our whole draft for Sam Darnold than just stick with Daniel Jones and not draft a QB
Sanders seems unreliable and Manning can’t come out yet.
1. Tank for the top pick
2. Trade that pick for a combo of picks and any established O-line or D-backs you can get.
3. Use whatever picks we do have on as many WR as possible.
4. Cut DJ loose.
5. Sign veteran QB to “prove it” deal.
6. Fire Schoen, keep Daboll (for now).
7. Begin rebuild, aim to have QB of the future in the next 2-3 years using pick or picks acquired in the (hypothetical #1 trade) or future picks.
8. Settle in, trust the process.
Edit: downvotes coming in from people who want us to waste a high pick on a mediocre QB prospect or the people who just wanna be able to say, “Tommy Cutlets!”
Yes let’s force a qb because it can’t possibly be worse…says every brain dead fan.
So you want to draft a QB, regardless if you think that QB is good or not? FWIW Ward and Sanders are the only prospects that might be worthy of a 1st round grade imo and personally I still want to see some more film out of them before I even feel comfortable saying that.
would you rather have penix or nabers?
if there isn’t a good qb prospect at whatever pick we have, don’t settle. i’d rather continue with a bridge qb until there’s a true qb 1 than settle with a good prospect and invest another 4 years of hope into it
What’s everyone’s obsession with Arch? He hasn’t done anything impressive in college yet. Everyone wants to wait another year for him but has he done anything to make us feel this way? Only good games have been against Mississippi St and…UTSA?? Don’t care what his name is, I’m not gonna pass on a player like Cam Ward and wait another year for a QB who hasn’t shown anything yet.
Nah let’s get Travis hunter and roll with jones for 8 more years.
Take a shot this year and if they fail take another shot next year. The giants burn first round picks all the time not any different if we do it with a qb
For the love of shit, did you guys not learn a fucking thing from Gettleman drafting Jones!? In 2018, Gettleman passed on a QB because he believed Eli still had it. When it became clear that Eli didn’t have it, Gettleman panicked and forced a QB pick (Jones), especially after the QB he wanted (Herbert) went back to school. This was a mistake that Schoen didn’t make last year. He tried to trade up for Maye, didn’t get him, and didn’t panic and took BPA.
How does anyone disagree with this? Sometimes I think Giants fans just want to be miserable
The Cardinals drafted Josh Rosen, found out he was shit, and didn’t hesitate to draft Kyler Murray the very next year. The Giants can’t get any worse from drafting Cam Ward, Shadeur, or whomever
Such a dumb take. Drafting a qb doesn’t mean we get a good qb. Not a sure thing bub
People also don’t realize Daboll doesn’t get to wait until the perfect draft to pick his GUY until he can be EVALUATED. This is the nfl, you take what you’re given or you sign someone. You can’t go 2-8 every year and blame it on not having your first choice of QB. This isn’t the local YMCA team.
If we draft a bust QB this year well guess what, we’ll probably be in a position to draft a new one next year and/or in 2027. Same thing the Cardinals did with Rosen. We just hung onto DJ for way too long that’s all
It’s crazy to me people don’t realize that Daboll will be on the last year of his contract and he’ll be trying to keep his job. There are morons in here thinking that he and Schoen will pass on a chance to develop their own QB??? They’re drafting a QB. Get over it.
Jones was projected in the 2nd round!!! It’s not the same.
If they hate this year’s crop, get a stopgap QB in free agency, and then trade back for more assets next year so they can get their guy, if he’s there.