[BBV] What do execs, analysts think of New York Giants GM Joe Schoen? We asked, and here are the answers
November 17, 2024
[BBV] What do execs, analysts think of New York Giants GM Joe Schoen? We asked, and here are the answers
9 comments
What I want to know is why he didn’t like any of McCarthy, Penix, or Nix.
Schoen’s biggest mistake was resigning DJ and making big swings to give him as much support as possible. The article also makes a great point about both sides of the line not being where it needs to be. Runyan and Eleumenor are great signings but don’t address the long term future of the OLINE past the schoen regime.
While other teams just straight up didn’t have a QB we pretended like we did have one.( In hindsight any QB is going to have at least some success with Barkley. ) I’m okay with letting Schoen operate without the anomaly that is DJ but he’s already wasted so much time with DJ the Giants HAVE to be relevant by this time next season
“When the Giants signed Daniel Jones in March of 2023, I did not love that decision, but when you looked deeply what were their options? In his four seasons before he signed, he threw 60 TDs/34 INTs and was coming off a Wild Card win. They were not in a position to draft any of the top quarterbacks in the 2023 draft except for Will Levis – and some thought that he would go sooner than he actually went”
Said this a few times. What were the options, Jimmy G? Carr? Levis? His best bet would have been rolling with Tyrod and I’m sure the fan base would have understood intentionally entering a rebuild following the best season we’d seen in a decade. Schoen was screwed regardless, especially since he would have pissed his boss off with what would have been the right decision. He’s done a fine job, there have been some misses but I’d challenge anyone to point me to a GM without a miss
The bust-washing of Evan Neal is wild. Dude gave up 4 sacks and 4 holding penalties over 3 years starting and over 2000 snaps at Alabama. He was the number 1 prospect regardless of position coming out. Everyone on this sub thought it was a home run at the time. No one had any clue things would turn out the way they did. Hopefully Neal can build on the relatively solid game he had last week, or move to guard like Mekhi Becton.
The first guy say, without irony and in all seriousness, that the Giants should have tried to get creative to trade up, with the Commanders, for Jayden Daniels.
No need to read the rest of that article. Jesus christ.
Schoen drafts bust after bust and this sub still wants to see more! Lol!
Mccreight sounds like an absolute moron
Schoen chose to trade 2nd round pick for Burns which i think was huge mistake and Pats might have considered it
that 2nd pick had a lot of value
160 over 4 yrs for DJ. No. That’s stupid any way you look at it. One or two yr deal sure. He bet the franchise on a mediocre qb with known neck issues and saquon doing the heavy lift. No.
![[BBV] What do execs, analysts think of New York Giants GM Joe Schoen? We asked, and here are the answers](https://www.rawchili.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Y_bx_QyiH3P6If0UOyBM6KqPZzldQhYhgpYbK4Iglrk.jpg)
9 comments
What I want to know is why he didn’t like any of McCarthy, Penix, or Nix.
Schoen’s biggest mistake was resigning DJ and making big swings to give him as much support as possible.
The article also makes a great point about both sides of the line not being where it needs to be. Runyan and Eleumenor are great signings but don’t address the long term future of the OLINE past the schoen regime.
While other teams just straight up didn’t have a QB we pretended like we did have one.( In hindsight any QB is going to have at least some success with Barkley. )
I’m okay with letting Schoen operate without the anomaly that is DJ but he’s already wasted so much time with DJ the Giants HAVE to be relevant by this time next season
“When the Giants signed Daniel Jones in March of 2023, I did not love that decision, but when you looked deeply what were their options? In his four seasons before he signed, he threw 60 TDs/34 INTs and was coming off a Wild Card win. They were not in a position to draft any of the top quarterbacks in the 2023 draft except for Will Levis – and some thought that he would go sooner than he actually went”
Said this a few times. What were the options, Jimmy G? Carr? Levis? His best bet would have been rolling with Tyrod and I’m sure the fan base would have understood intentionally entering a rebuild following the best season we’d seen in a decade. Schoen was screwed regardless, especially since he would have pissed his boss off with what would have been the right decision. He’s done a fine job, there have been some misses but I’d challenge anyone to point me to a GM without a miss
The bust-washing of Evan Neal is wild. Dude gave up 4 sacks and 4 holding penalties over 3 years starting and over 2000 snaps at Alabama. He was the number 1 prospect regardless of position coming out. Everyone on this sub thought it was a home run at the time. No one had any clue things would turn out the way they did. Hopefully Neal can build on the relatively solid game he had last week, or move to guard like Mekhi Becton.
The first guy say, without irony and in all seriousness, that the Giants should have tried to get creative to trade up, with the Commanders, for Jayden Daniels.
No need to read the rest of that article. Jesus christ.
Schoen drafts bust after bust and this sub still wants to see more! Lol!
Mccreight sounds like an absolute moron
Schoen chose to trade 2nd round pick for Burns which i think was huge mistake and Pats might have considered it
that 2nd pick had a lot of value
160 over 4 yrs for DJ. No. That’s stupid any way you look at it. One or two yr deal sure. He bet the franchise on a mediocre qb with known neck issues and saquon doing the heavy lift. No.