Probably the one where every single stat is better except for one
This graphic is terribly designed
Umm. This is a stupid comparison. It’s obvious. A few HRs do not make for a better season.
2024
Going by overall value, undoubtedly 2024. Going by historical and memorable, be spoken about in decades from now, 2022.
People like records even if well-roundedness is statistically better. It sucks for the amazing well rounded players, but people will remember Stanton more than Lindor and (maybe I’m a homer for this one, but anyways) Judge more than Betts. Not saying it should be that way, just that it is. Hell, even Trout, the undisputed best if his generation, would be spoken about more if he would break some more traditional stat records
The one with the better numbers.
.458 OBP is something I haven’t seen anyone close to in a long time
Definitely 2024.
We were a broken foot in 2023 away from one of the best 3 year stretches in baseball history
Still insane to me that he didn’t look like he belonged in the league for the majority of April and then turned it into a season that was better than one of the most ridiculous seasons of all time
Crazy cause I feel those 4 extra HR’s, or the fact that he reached 60 kinda outshine everything else. People were definitely more hyped for him in 2022, but he really improved this year along with Stanton and Soto
Did the wall in Baltimore stop him from back to back 60 HR seasons?
one of these is better across the board i dont think four home runs makes up for that quite frankly
The bat looks like a child’s toy in his hands. He’s a beast.
Should be his third MVP. Pisses me off to this day. But hey better to be pissed off than pissed on
*
Playoff turd
2024 obv
Is this a trick question?
1st one is more consistent. 2nd one he went nuclear minus one month. Imagine if he had a good first month is past year he would have 65 probably
And yet. Choked in the postseason when most needed.
2024, but his World Series play will come back and haunt him, especially that error in the 5th inning of game 5. His slump in the playoffs put a pretty big stain on a remarkable regular season.
Can’t hit when it matters
Now do that in the post season judge. Or anything close to it
27 comments
Now do 2017 when that cheater stole it from him
Dude really ?
Probably the one where every single stat is better except for one
This graphic is terribly designed
Umm. This is a stupid comparison. It’s obvious. A few HRs do not make for a better season.
2024
Going by overall value, undoubtedly 2024. Going by historical and memorable, be spoken about in decades from now, 2022.
People like records even if well-roundedness is statistically better. It sucks for the amazing well rounded players, but people will remember Stanton more than Lindor and (maybe I’m a homer for this one, but anyways) Judge more than Betts. Not saying it should be that way, just that it is. Hell, even Trout, the undisputed best if his generation, would be spoken about more if he would break some more traditional stat records
The one with the better numbers.
.458 OBP is something I haven’t seen anyone close to in a long time
Definitely 2024.
We were a broken foot in 2023 away from one of the best 3 year stretches in baseball history
Still insane to me that he didn’t look like he belonged in the league for the majority of April and then turned it into a season that was better than one of the most ridiculous seasons of all time
Crazy cause I feel those 4 extra HR’s, or the fact that he reached 60 kinda outshine everything else. People were definitely more hyped for him in 2022, but he really improved this year along with Stanton and Soto
Did the wall in Baltimore stop him from back to back 60 HR seasons?
one of these is better across the board i dont think four home runs makes up for that quite frankly
The bat looks like a child’s toy in his hands. He’s a beast.
Should be his third MVP. Pisses me off to this day. But hey better to be pissed off than pissed on
*
Playoff turd
2024 obv
Is this a trick question?
1st one is more consistent. 2nd one he went nuclear minus one month. Imagine if he had a good first month is past year he would have 65 probably
And yet. Choked in the postseason when most needed.
2024, but his World Series play will come back and haunt him, especially that error in the 5th inning of game 5. His slump in the playoffs put a pretty big stain on a remarkable regular season.
Can’t hit when it matters
Now do that in the post season judge. Or anything close to it
Pointless post