Any potential Bregman contract will be an albatross by year 3
This isn’t much of an upgrade and certainly not the price tag
Honestly surprised Bohm only hit 15 out this year.
Guess he was more of a doubles machine, but felt like he had more than 15 HR..!
Keep Bohm, the dude is good. He’s young and still developing.
“We have Bregman at home!”
fuck Bregman
Even if I can see that bregman is slightly better than bohm he is nowhere near worth the increase in price.
I’ll be furious if they panic and bail on the plan of letting bohm play out his arbitration years and then let him go when Miller is ready to take over. The last thing this team needs is another long-term contract that will age poorly. Especially for a player that’s absolutely not a given to solve the ills of this lineup.
Show me their playoff stats
Would make zero sense.
Compare the age and the salary!! No question. This argument is trash
Yeah man i dont get it at all. Id rather resign bohm and keep letting him develop and get better! He was on fire in the first half so we’ve see it happen.
Feel like the salary comparison is pretty important… Bohm is a little off a multi-million dollar player making way, way less.
Bregman is not worth $300M+
If we sign Bregman to anything longer than 2-3 years we’d essentially be making Aidan Miller obsolete no? Maybe he could take over 2nd and we move on from Stott but I’d rather we just roll with Bohm til Miller is ready to take over 3rd. Bregman isn’t some massive upgrade over Bohm. Not worth it.
I rather have a team of head cases than 1 crooked cheater on the Phillies.
No Bregman. Never. I don’t want him near my Phillies.
Let’s say their regular season stats are a wash, Bregman is the veteran guy you bring in for the playoffs with two World Series wins under his belt, and experience in four, and decent overall playoff stats. He also was in MVP consideration in 18, 19, 22, and 23 – coming in 2nd in 2019. Bohm would be entering his 6th season – He is who he is at this point.
So by WAR Bregman is worth only one extra win? Does that mean they’re basically the same player?
Bohm is younger cheaper areguably better and actually a player we drafted and developed. Would hate to see bohm go, and I’m still annoyed that topper lets most other players do whatever they want (casty was horrible for 2 months and never sat) then he benches bohm in playoffs
Can we please let this die
This lineup needs OBP
Dombrowski is dead to me if he does this swap. Yeah let’s pay an extra 20 million for another old declining player and probably get back dogshit for Bohm. Pass
Just stick with Bohm.
Huh, can i still yell cheater?
We’re not giving credit to Bregman’s championships?
Yeah this makes no sense
I see no reason to trade Bohm with his stats, his All Star status, his hitting in almost every game and the RBIs from those hits and his defense etc however if they keep him maybe this’ll teach him to control his hissy phits.
Nobody is talking about if the Astros lose Bregman, we then offer him in a trade for Tucker. Bohm+Crawford+____+_____(may)= Tucker.
If we get rid of our bright young all star and waste all our money for a washed up bum from I team I dispise ill be so fkn pissed off.
I’d take Bohm every single time over bregman
I’m not for Bregman, cuz fuck him, but they are only 2 years apart in age, and Bregman just won a gold glove. I don’t think the age argument holds that much weight, really…..and the defensive improvement would be drastic.
We have perfectly good Bregman at home.
Bohm it is.
While I agree that he’s overvalued, it’s a bit disingenuous to compare Bregman’s probably worse year with Bohm’s best, even though it’s last year.
Has 1.1 more Win Above Replacement
Has worse stats in almost every category
What
Not a huge fan of either Bohm or Bregman. I’d definitely say Bregman is better, but for what he’d cost, I’d probably rather keep Bohm through the arbitration years and use the money elsewhere (or trade him and figure out another shorter-term replacement). Not sure Bregman would be worth the difference in AAV between Bohm / Bregman’s salary, nor the additional guaranteed commitment beyond when Bohm’s arbitration years run out.
Bregman also had a down year. His OBP for his career is usually in the .360 range
I think, with some mental coaching, Bohm could develop into something special. I look at Bregman and I don’t see him as any kind of improvement.
Bohm gets upset because he’s passionate about the game. That’s not a defect. Teach him how to channel that.
This should not even be up for discussion.
This team has way more important holes to fill…….we’ve got an aging Catcher who frankly had a terrible offensive year, a shortstop who is neurotic in the field and at the plate, a bunch of ho-hum CF & LF options, a 2B who took a step backwards in 2024…..even Harper was plagued by injury, Bohm had been the steadiest position player we had and his age makes him all the mre attractive.
The Phils are fast becoming a very expensive old age home……great starting staff, and until the playoffs a great bullpen, but goddamn if Outfield should not be our #1 priority. #B Bohm is the least of our concerns
41 comments
Bregman is absolutely not worth $350M
Any potential Bregman contract will be an albatross by year 3
This isn’t much of an upgrade and certainly not the price tag
Honestly surprised Bohm only hit 15 out this year.
Guess he was more of a doubles machine, but felt like he had more than 15 HR..!
Keep Bohm, the dude is good. He’s young and still developing.
“We have Bregman at home!”
fuck Bregman
Even if I can see that bregman is slightly better than bohm he is nowhere near worth the increase in price.
I’ll be furious if they panic and bail on the plan of letting bohm play out his arbitration years and then let him go when Miller is ready to take over. The last thing this team needs is another long-term contract that will age poorly. Especially for a player that’s absolutely not a given to solve the ills of this lineup.
Show me their playoff stats
Would make zero sense.
Compare the age and the salary!! No question. This argument is trash
Yeah man i dont get it at all. Id rather resign bohm and keep letting him develop and get better! He was on fire in the first half so we’ve see it happen.
Feel like the salary comparison is pretty important… Bohm is a little off a multi-million dollar player making way, way less.
Bregman is not worth $300M+
If we sign Bregman to anything longer than 2-3 years we’d essentially be making Aidan Miller obsolete no? Maybe he could take over 2nd and we move on from Stott but I’d rather we just roll with Bohm til Miller is ready to take over 3rd. Bregman isn’t some massive upgrade over Bohm. Not worth it.
I rather have a team of head cases than 1 crooked cheater on the Phillies.
No Bregman. Never. I don’t want him near my Phillies.
Let’s say their regular season stats are a wash, Bregman is the veteran guy you bring in for the playoffs with two World Series wins under his belt, and experience in four, and decent overall playoff stats. He also was in MVP consideration in 18, 19, 22, and 23 – coming in 2nd in 2019. Bohm would be entering his 6th season – He is who he is at this point.
So by WAR Bregman is worth only one extra win? Does that mean they’re basically the same player?
Bohm is younger cheaper areguably better and actually a player we drafted and developed. Would hate to see bohm go, and I’m still annoyed that topper lets most other players do whatever they want (casty was horrible for 2 months and never sat) then he benches bohm in playoffs
Can we please let this die
This lineup needs OBP
Dombrowski is dead to me if he does this swap. Yeah let’s pay an extra 20 million for another old declining player and probably get back dogshit for Bohm. Pass
Just stick with Bohm.
Huh, can i still yell cheater?
We’re not giving credit to Bregman’s championships?
Yeah this makes no sense
I see no reason to trade Bohm with his stats, his All Star status, his hitting in almost every game and the RBIs from those hits and his defense etc however if they keep him maybe this’ll teach him to control his hissy phits.
Nobody is talking about if the Astros lose Bregman, we then offer him in a trade for Tucker. Bohm+Crawford+____+_____(may)= Tucker.
If we get rid of our bright young all star and waste all our money for a washed up bum from I team I dispise ill be so fkn pissed off.
I’d take Bohm every single time over bregman
I’m not for Bregman, cuz fuck him, but they are only 2 years apart in age, and Bregman just won a gold glove. I don’t think the age argument holds that much weight, really…..and the defensive improvement would be drastic.
We have perfectly good Bregman at home.
Bohm it is.
While I agree that he’s overvalued, it’s a bit disingenuous to compare Bregman’s probably worse year with Bohm’s best, even though it’s last year.
Has 1.1 more Win Above Replacement
Has worse stats in almost every category
What
Not a huge fan of either Bohm or Bregman. I’d definitely say Bregman is better, but for what he’d cost, I’d probably rather keep Bohm through the arbitration years and use the money elsewhere (or trade him and figure out another shorter-term replacement). Not sure Bregman would be worth the difference in AAV between Bohm / Bregman’s salary, nor the additional guaranteed commitment beyond when Bohm’s arbitration years run out.
Bregman also had a down year. His OBP for his career is usually in the .360 range
I think, with some mental coaching, Bohm could develop into something special. I look at Bregman and I don’t see him as any kind of improvement.
Bohm gets upset because he’s passionate about the game. That’s not a defect. Teach him how to channel that.
This should not even be up for discussion.
This team has way more important holes to fill…….we’ve got an aging Catcher who frankly had a terrible offensive year, a shortstop who is neurotic in the field and at the plate, a bunch of ho-hum CF & LF options, a 2B who took a step backwards in 2024…..even Harper was plagued by injury, Bohm had been the steadiest position player we had and his age makes him all the mre attractive.
The Phils are fast becoming a very expensive old age home……great starting staff, and until the playoffs a great bullpen, but goddamn if Outfield should not be our #1 priority. #B Bohm is the least of our concerns