The Completely Lost New York Giants

31 comments

1. PT the biggest mistake that Joe made was not staying the rebuild course after the Giants made that fluke playoff run with Jones. Somehow they came to the conclusion that one all right season from Jones wiped out all the really bad ones and decided that he needed a contract extension and that this team had arrived and it hadn’t they miscalculated and overvalued their roster and they move the goal post up on themselves When this team was still two or three years out from actually contending. They also extremely undervalued the value of not only Barkley as a special player, but Barkley in his ability to cover up for the issues that Jones presented.

2. I am tired of hearing about Josh Allen and I am tired of hearing about 2022, Josh Allen would be great with any coach

3. I agree with PTpigeonholed themselves into selecting a quarterback, but I know it’s not conventional but let’s say they take a quarterback and they end up being horrible again next year and another quarterback like arch. Manny is right there for them to take you take arch Manning and you figure it out later you don’t pass on arch Manning because you took Cam Ward the year prior if you feel like Manning is the far better prospect and you happen to be in position to take him.

4. If they bring the same coach and gm back they win 3 games at most next year

5. Re Jones: nobody could fix him. In 2022 he was a one trick pony. When the league caught on Jones didn't have the talent to step up higher

6. I have to say this in Daboll defense. All season long just about the entire team did not execute. Daniel Jones did not make the correct reads. This was no more evident on that 4th down flea-flicker when he had no less than two WR's wide open down field and Jones kept running backwards for a huge sack. Sine '22 when Jones was averaging 6.8 yards per pass, he followed up with 6.1 average and then a 5.7 average and he stopped running as much which was the best part of his game. #5 KT is a player that pass rush only. Too many times I have seen RB's fake him out and run right around him. Trade him. If not be ready for a huge contract. How many missed tackles?

7. I just can't trust John Mara to get anything right anymore. He needs to get totally out of the football decisions. We need a new George Young but I'm not sure there is one out there.

8. As a giant fan, we've see Worse seasons❓️ like hermanad edwards Fumble recovery we could have been in the playoffs that year I'd still hurt What's the bad?
   Then comes the good.Have faith Is giant fan12 16 24 👍👍

9. People complaining about dave gettlemen where completely wrong look at all the pics he gave us

10. The can't draft and they can evaluate and develop.

11. If they stick with Schoen and/or Dabol, the fanbase will revolt. And if you keep Schoen, what kind of head coach and coaching staff are you going to get to come in and work for a lame duck GM?

12. Spot on Patty with your insight. Let’s hope it can get better moving forward however that needs to happen…

13. Pattie they have to go. It don’t make sense for them ( daboll and schoen) to pick their qb and enter into the next season already on the hot seat. Then if they fail you will have to go through the hiring process once again and who knows if the new regime wants the qb that they picked. Get them out now

14. What would you have the coaches & Schoen do with 3 games left that they dont have an icecube's chance in hell? Did Parcells deserve to come back when he was losing like crazy? How about George Young? This regime started the rebuild last draft & did a great job. Start looking beyond the end of this season, everyone. The build has started and needs to be allowed to continue. Imagine what would've happened had Mara dumped Parcellss.

15. Dear God, let this nightmare season end already…with a dream number 1 pick!!

16. Wossamotta U. The college where Bullwinkle J Moose went. That would be the only team I would watch from here on out.

17. Who's going to want to work or play for the Gisnts. Good luck getting some fool to work for the Giants.

18. Give it to who? JS was definitely counting on the draft. He is building the team,X and Barkley wasn't his choices.. His choices of the team structure are- Burns,Ward, Phillips,Nabers…

19. I just checked the depth chart and could not believe how many original starters that are injured. Not to mention the cuts we made and not resigning some players that are playing great for other teams. Few leaders left in the locker room. Horrible. And no quarterback is worth a #1 pick this year.

20. Patricia, maybe, just maybe this is John Mara fault? When he hired Shoen and Daboll he mentioned that they did EVERYTHING to srew up Daniel Jones. Shoen is all about business not personal feelings..look at how he parted ways with Barkley (their best player on offense) I say that if they had their druthers they would have gotten rid of Jones so long ago.

21. Yeah need therapy after watching the giants

22. Few if any of the giants starters would be starters on any other team

23. Wellington Mara only had one banner airplane flying over Giants Stadium before he took action.

    John Mara and Steve Tisch have had two banner airplanes so far.

    Bye Bye Daboll / Schoen.

24. How many losses do we need in 2025 before Schoen and Daboll are fired?

25. I now root for them to lose

26. The worst part of being part of this teams fandom, is having to listen to media people constantly saying to fire the coach and/or GM. They’re inherently toxic. Let the football people do their jobs. They were forced to give DJ a contract by ownership. Now let them get their qb in here and see how they do. This is the difference between Steelers and us. Our annoying media.

27. Michael Penix, the 4th qb taken in last years draft is arguably better than the top 3 QBs this year

28. We've seen more then enough Joe Schoen and Brian Daboll have failed miserably

    They must be fired RIGHT NOW

29. Don’t see the Eagles resting their starters. They are tied with Detroit for the #1 seed and bye week.

30. Losing to Philly’s backups w Saquon getting the record & resting is the worst

31. Can not keep listening to You Patty.
    Stop stirring the pot…!
    How many teams are similar records?…
    DJ and his contract, set us back all this years….
    And more than that…!!!