[RedsFanChris] The Reds were 13-32 in games started by Luke Maile in 2024. I don’t think that will be the case with Jose Trevino in 2025. For that reason alone this trade is worth it.
December 21, 2024
[RedsFanChris] The Reds were 13-32 in games started by Luke Maile in 2024. I don’t think that will be the case with Jose Trevino in 2025. For that reason alone this trade is worth it.
9 comments
that’s the difference between making and missing the playoffs
We needed better options at C but to imply that Maile personally lost ~10 games is just dumb.
Backup catcher is *not* a position that winning organizations hang their hats on. Conceptually putting the blame for that record on one single player is patently ridiculous.
This team has other needs that need to be prioritized before they can be taken seriously. Acquiring Trevino is not an impact move.
sounds like an issue where the roster wasn’t good enough at hitting to give their starting catcher games off
What do they think our record in games started by Luke Maile will be this year now that we have Jose Trevino
People don’t get how big of an upgrade Trevino is over what we’ve had.
It wasn’t talked about enough how bad Maile was. Classic case of great guy who should probably be a coach.
Maile was awful.
I love the sabermetric gymnastics on this sub sometimes used to justify horribly underwhelming, small market team trades. Sure. Maile lost us a bunch of games and Trevino has a higher wtfbbq+ so we’ll pick up 7-10 wins. Cool.
![[RedsFanChris] The Reds were 13-32 in games started by Luke Maile in 2024. I don’t think that will be the case with Jose Trevino in 2025. For that reason alone this trade is worth it.](https://www.rawchili.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/Q5ikOGAzqJVANlIIvy6Mntg4jAbhqr0LHZZoP1TzGfE.jpg)
9 comments
that’s the difference between making and missing the playoffs
We needed better options at C but to imply that Maile personally lost ~10 games is just dumb.
Backup catcher is *not* a position that winning organizations hang their hats on. Conceptually putting the blame for that record on one single player is patently ridiculous.
This team has other needs that need to be prioritized before they can be taken seriously. Acquiring Trevino is not an impact move.
sounds like an issue where the roster wasn’t good enough at hitting to give their starting catcher games off
What do they think our record in games started by Luke Maile will be this year now that we have Jose Trevino
People don’t get how big of an upgrade Trevino is over what we’ve had.
It wasn’t talked about enough how bad Maile was. Classic case of great guy who should probably be a coach.
Maile was awful.
I love the sabermetric gymnastics on this sub sometimes used to justify horribly underwhelming, small market team trades. Sure. Maile lost us a bunch of games and Trevino has a higher wtfbbq+ so we’ll pick up 7-10 wins. Cool.