Torii Hunter, Manny Ramirez, Ichiro Suzuki, CC Sabathia
Ichiro….then a distant Beltran.
Ichiro, Wagner, CC, Pettite, vizquel and Beltran.
F I’m old… Tier 1 Ichiro
Tier 2 Beltran Felix
Steroid: Manny Arod
Fernando Rodney being included on here has to be some sort of “where’s Waldo” joke right?
Kinsler?
Ichiro and Sabathia
It’s a crime Andruw Jones isn’t in yet.
CHASE UTLEY
If I only had 3 votes, I’m going ichiro, CC, and andruw. I think torii would be much higher if he played in a bigger market. Him and andruw are possibly the best defensive cf’ers of the past 40-50 years
Respectfully, I hate your ballot.
To me, the Hall of Fame is irrelevant until Barry Bonds is inducted.
Ichiro should not even be on the ballet. Should have received a call on day one and told made the HOF.
Ichiro and Wagner this year.
My ballot: Ichiro, Beltran, Andruw Jones, Manny*, A-Rod*, Utley, Wagner, CC
**Bud Selig is in so the steroid gatekeeping is nonsense. He only did something after Congress went sniffing around, the worm
Why does everyone hate closers so much? KRod should be in. He has more saves than 5 closers who are already in the Hall. 6th all time in saves. Wtf
Ichiro, CC, Beltran, Manny, A-Rod, Utley, Pettitte, Felix
Fuck Manny Machado
Ichiro, Felix (The King), and Omar
It’s just gonna be ichiro and Wagner
Ichiro, CC, Wagner, K-Rod, Beltran, Jones… beyond that idc.
Hall of the very good ass list. Ichiro and that’s it.
Ichiro and that’s it
Abreu deserves some love. I’m not sure he deserves a slot but a few votes at least.
Bobby Abreu should be in. Here is why.
2 players have played 13+ consecutive seasons of 150+ games. The other? Willie Mays.
*Gift Ripken, Rose, Rafi (strikes) and Gehrig (rain shortened season)* this as well.
100 BB + 98 Run season +8 seasons? Ruth. Gehrig. Williams. Thome. Thomas. Bonds. and… ABREU.
His OBP is 7 points higher than Tony Gwynn!
He is hurt only by offensive metrics of his time that were conflated due to steroids. He was an auto start OFer for 15+ seasons on championship competing clubs.
Someone with the equivalent of Dustin Pedroia’s career in the nba would have a serous chance of making the HOF. But he won’t even sniff it I don’t think. Personally I like the exclusivity
46 comments
Goodness gracious
Ichiro is going first ballot babyyyyyyyyyy 🤞🏻
Most definitely will be Ichiro. At some point, maybe CC, Dustin, Troy
What is Brian McCann doing on there?
Ichiro should be unanimous
Beltrán definitely has the numbers
Ichiro, A Rod & Felix
No bias/no flair
Ichiro. That’s it.
Manny Ramirez, Ichiro, Alex Rodriguez are no-brainers. Beltran is damn close, but not quite there, IMO.
Ichiro. That is all.
Ichiro, Dustin and Felix
I just love that Rodney’s hat is comically askew in this picture.
CC and Ichiro should get in. Pedroia and Felix will get a second ballot. A lot of the other first timers won’t though I think. Top heavy batch.
18 of these guys have no business being on the ballot.
Who should be in but won’t and likely never will: ARod, Manny
Who should likely be in: Ichiro, CC, Jones
Who I want to get in for various reasons but likely won’t: Rollins, Zobrist, Vizquel
Ichiro and Felix. Maybe pedoria
Beltran, Andruw, ManRam, ARod, Sabathia, Ichiro, Utley, Wagner
Wagner should be in 100%
Ichiro and CC. 3000 hits and 3000 strikeouts.
Wagner, Ichiro, Sabathia, Beltran
Torii Hunter, Manny Ramirez, Ichiro Suzuki, CC Sabathia
Ichiro….then a distant Beltran.
Ichiro, Wagner, CC, Pettite, vizquel and Beltran.
F I’m old…
Tier 1
Ichiro
Tier 2
Beltran
Felix
Steroid:
Manny
Arod
Fernando Rodney being included on here has to be some sort of “where’s Waldo” joke right?
Kinsler?
Ichiro and Sabathia
It’s a crime Andruw Jones isn’t in yet.
CHASE UTLEY
If I only had 3 votes, I’m going ichiro, CC, and andruw. I think torii would be much higher if he played in a bigger market. Him and andruw are possibly the best defensive cf’ers of the past 40-50 years
Respectfully, I hate your ballot.
To me, the Hall of Fame is irrelevant until Barry Bonds is inducted.
Ichiro should not even be on the ballet. Should have received a call on day one and told made the HOF.
Ichiro and Wagner this year.
My ballot: Ichiro, Beltran, Andruw Jones, Manny*, A-Rod*, Utley, Wagner, CC
**Bud Selig is in so the steroid gatekeeping is nonsense. He only did something after Congress went sniffing around, the worm
Why does everyone hate closers so much? KRod should be in. He has more saves than 5 closers who are already in the Hall. 6th all time in saves. Wtf
Ichiro, CC, Beltran, Manny, A-Rod, Utley, Pettitte, Felix
Fuck Manny Machado
Ichiro, Felix (The King), and Omar
It’s just gonna be ichiro and Wagner
Ichiro, CC, Wagner, K-Rod, Beltran, Jones… beyond that idc.
Hall of the very good ass list. Ichiro and that’s it.
Ichiro and that’s it
Abreu deserves some love. I’m not sure he deserves a slot but a few votes at least.
Bobby Abreu should be in. Here is why.
2 players have played 13+ consecutive seasons of 150+ games. The other? Willie Mays.
*Gift Ripken, Rose, Rafi (strikes) and Gehrig (rain shortened season)* this as well.
100 BB + 98 Run season +8 seasons? Ruth. Gehrig. Williams. Thome. Thomas. Bonds. and… ABREU.
His OBP is 7 points higher than Tony Gwynn!
He is hurt only by offensive metrics of his time that were conflated due to steroids. He was an auto start OFer for 15+ seasons on championship competing clubs.
Someone with the equivalent of Dustin Pedroia’s career in the nba would have a serous chance of making the HOF. But he won’t even sniff it I don’t think. Personally I like the exclusivity