None of the above. It’s Papi and everyone fucking knows it.

37 comments
  1. Yeah what meaningful thing has A-Rod done even comparable to the greatest clutch hitter in baseball history?

  2. If you need somebody to slap a ball out of a glove the arod is your guy. Otherwise it’s big papi

  3. Didn’t the sabremetricians supposedly prove there’s no such thing as “clutch,” though? That always puzzled me because clearly players like Papi have some clutch touch of some kind.

  4. Insane to put judge on there and leave out the most clutch player to ever play the game

  5. Don’t like him, but Bonds was intentionally walked with the bases loaded. Just saying.

  6. I’d expect a strikeout from Judge, a flyout or strikeout from a rod, a double from Griffey and a homer from Bonds.

  7. Aaron Judge is unironically one of the biggest losers in the history of sports

  8. I’d say bonds but he’d just get walked, ain’t looking for just 1 run

  9. 1. David Big Papi Ortiz
    2. Bonds
    3. If no grand slam, Tony Gwynn. Whoever at 2nd and 3rd are gonna score.

  10. depends, I’m taking papi if it’s just regular bonds, but if this is roided up Barry bonds then probably bonds.

  11. Well, it’s Big Papi 99% of the time unless you intentionally walk Garciaparra and then it’s Troy O’Leary

  12. Of the list it’s bonds assuming they actually have to pitch to him and can’t walk him but Papi being left off the list is a travesty

Leave a Reply