Remember that 1 season Steve Smith kicked ass b4 Hakeem Nicks broke out the following year?
Ahem, it says Mediocre. Get Manningham’s name out of your mouth.
Joe Jurevicius
Rubeus Randle lol
Kevin boss
Ike Hilliard or Chris Calloway baby
Ike Hilliard is the GOAT
Chris Calloway
Phil McConkey!
I feel old reading this thread.
Still mad Plaxico shot himself in the leg 😭
Toomer was my WR growing up, he was anything but mediocre.
Sinorice Moss.
He wasn’t in any way(imo) mediocre, but obj is the reason i support the giants/started watching the nfl as an international fan
I was always waiting for the manningham break out
Idk if Toomer was mediocre 🤷🏻♂️
Steve smith
Ike Hillard and Amani Toomer.
No love for Ernest Gray?
Me but with Jason Seahorn
Tavares 👑
I know it’s TE but I loved me some Leaping Larry
Gonna date myself here; Chris Calloway
Look atvyall remembering the great yesterday but hate to give Jerry Reese his credit for building those memories. Not one player drafted or signed by the past two GM’s have made an impact compared to those of Jerry Reese. Position by position, Reese was a far better evaluator of talent.
Henry Hynoski (Not a WR)
Toomer was at the tail end of his career but definitely not mediocre
Reuben Randle, oddly
Ike Hilliard for me.
Manningham was not mediocre
Phil McConkey FTW
Mark Ingram
Hakeem nicks would have been HOF status if he never had that career ending injury IDGAF what anyone says
… I know you didn’t just call Super Bowl hero Mario Manningham mediocre? He was legitimately a good WR. Go watch his plays in the XLVI post season, especially @. SF. Absolute baller.
I look at this and think more of truly average WRs ie Domenik Hixon.
Phil McConkey.
Ed McCaffrey was sort of mediocre for us but I was a fan.
Domenik Hixon 🥹🥹🥹
Stephen “Touchdown Maker” Baker, the great white hope ED McCaffery and Thomas Lewis. To this day my buddy and I laugh cuz I was so hyped for Lewis one season because I read in the Giants News Weekly that he pit on 15 lbs of muscle.in the off-season and I was sure he was going to set NFL records that year because of it.
Sinorice Moss. I’m a younger brother, and was CONVINCED that Santana’s younger brother would be way better because all younger brothers are inherently better than older brothers.
Ramses Barden
He was straight bad but I remember being so hyped when they drafted Sinorice Moss lol
Ron Dixon. That KR TD in the Divisional round sealed it for me.
41 comments
Loved me some Domenick hixon
Remember that 1 season Steve Smith kicked ass b4 Hakeem Nicks broke out the following year?
Ahem, it says Mediocre. Get Manningham’s name out of your mouth.
Joe Jurevicius
Rubeus Randle lol
Kevin boss
Ike Hilliard or Chris Calloway baby
Ike Hilliard is the GOAT
Chris Calloway
Phil McConkey!
I feel old reading this thread.
Still mad Plaxico shot himself in the leg 😭
Toomer was my WR growing up, he was anything but mediocre.
Sinorice Moss.
He wasn’t in any way(imo) mediocre, but obj is the reason i support the giants/started watching the nfl as an international fan
I was always waiting for the manningham break out
Idk if Toomer was mediocre 🤷🏻♂️
Steve smith
Ike Hillard and Amani Toomer.
No love for Ernest Gray?
Me but with Jason Seahorn
Tavares 👑
I know it’s TE but I loved me some Leaping Larry
Gonna date myself here; Chris Calloway
Look atvyall remembering the great yesterday but hate to give Jerry Reese his credit for building those memories. Not one player drafted or signed by the past two GM’s have made an impact compared to those of Jerry Reese. Position by position, Reese was a far better evaluator of talent.
Henry Hynoski (Not a WR)
Toomer was at the tail end of his career but definitely not mediocre
Reuben Randle, oddly
Ike Hilliard for me.
Manningham was not mediocre
Phil McConkey FTW
Mark Ingram
Hakeem nicks would have been HOF status if he never had that career ending injury IDGAF what anyone says
… I know you didn’t just call Super Bowl hero Mario Manningham mediocre? He was legitimately a good WR. Go watch his plays in the XLVI post season, especially @. SF. Absolute baller.
I look at this and think more of truly average WRs ie Domenik Hixon.
Phil McConkey.
Ed McCaffrey was sort of mediocre for us but I was a fan.
Domenik Hixon 🥹🥹🥹
Stephen “Touchdown Maker” Baker, the great white hope ED McCaffery and Thomas Lewis. To this day my buddy and I laugh cuz I was so hyped for Lewis one season because I read in the Giants News Weekly that he pit on 15 lbs of muscle.in the off-season and I was sure he was going to set NFL records that year because of it.
Sinorice Moss. I’m a younger brother, and was CONVINCED that Santana’s younger brother would be way better because all younger brothers are inherently better than older brothers.
Ramses Barden
He was straight bad but I remember being so hyped when they drafted Sinorice Moss lol
Ron Dixon. That KR TD in the Divisional round sealed it for me.