Who would you take Reggie Wayne or Marvin Harrison
October 12, 2024
Who would you take Reggie Wayne or Marvin Harrison
27 comments
Is this a shitpost?
We got both. NO picking anything. Legends!
I would take a QB that can finish a game, a kicker that can make a 50yd, and a team that could win the division.
This can’t possibly be a serious post.
I love Reggie. Hell, probably every Colts fan does. But Marvin is the clear cut choice and it really isn’t remotely close.
Reggie Harrison
Orange Glove Reggie was a dog, I’m taking Reg
Reggie was amazing and is my favorite of the two. But, Marvin was in conversation of the best WR during his prime and you could argue is a top 10-15 WR of all time.
Pierre Garcon
Marv during the early Manning years. Reggie during the late Manning/early Luck years.
Reggie in the playoffs, Marvin in the regular season.
I believe Reggie would even choose Marvin. And I LOVE Reggie Wayne
Marvin all day every day
Yes.
Wayne train all day
I’ll say what I always say when this silly question gets asked: Reggie is in the HOF conversation, but Marv is in the GOAT conversation
Marvin. But I would not ask him about his private life. And I would never rent a place from him.
We had both so we don’t have to choose lol. It’s a tough decision for everyone else though lol
Wayne was my favourite. Amazing at everything.
Harrison struggled Vs physicality and rleies on route running and his hands too much, which is okay, but I loved Wayne’s playstyle better.
We probably won’t at least 1 more ring with Peyton if he targeted Wayne more in the playoffs
I think it’s probably a little dangerous to publicly say anyone but Marvin.
That is some post history you got there, OP
Wayne
I think the only situation you’d take Reggie is if you had a lot of locker room troubles. Obviously, Marvin has a spotty history off the field, whereas I feel like Reggie could be more of a leader in the locker room.
But on the field, Marvin clears. And I had a fat head of Reggie on my wall until I was 23.
Unless the comparison is Marvin vs. Rice, The answer is Marvin.
Marvin all day. Top 10 WR of all time, wouldnt out reggie anywhere before the top 50
88 is my guy!
Reggie is one of my favorite, if not favorite colt ever but you gotta go with marvin. he’s was an extremely rare and elite talent at the position.
still absolutely love reggie wayne from stately wayne manor
27 comments
Is this a shitpost?
We got both. NO picking anything. Legends!
I would take a QB that can finish a game, a kicker that can make a 50yd, and a team that could win the division.
This can’t possibly be a serious post.
I love Reggie. Hell, probably every Colts fan does. But Marvin is the clear cut choice and it really isn’t remotely close.
Reggie Harrison
Orange Glove Reggie was a dog, I’m taking Reg
Reggie was amazing and is my favorite of the two. But, Marvin was in conversation of the best WR during his prime and you could argue is a top 10-15 WR of all time.
Pierre Garcon
Marv during the early Manning years. Reggie during the late Manning/early Luck years.
Reggie in the playoffs, Marvin in the regular season.
I believe Reggie would even choose Marvin. And I LOVE Reggie Wayne
Marvin all day every day
Yes.
Wayne train all day
I’ll say what I always say when this silly question gets asked: Reggie is in the HOF conversation, but Marv is in the GOAT conversation
Marvin. But I would not ask him about his private life. And I would never rent a place from him.
We had both so we don’t have to choose lol. It’s a tough decision for everyone else though lol
Wayne was my favourite.
Amazing at everything.
Harrison struggled Vs physicality and rleies on route running and his hands too much, which is okay, but I loved Wayne’s playstyle better.
We probably won’t at least 1 more ring with Peyton if he targeted Wayne more in the playoffs
I think it’s probably a little dangerous to publicly say anyone but Marvin.
That is some post history you got there, OP
Wayne
I think the only situation you’d take Reggie is if you had a lot of locker room troubles. Obviously, Marvin has a spotty history off the field, whereas I feel like Reggie could be more of a leader in the locker room.
But on the field, Marvin clears. And I had a fat head of Reggie on my wall until I was 23.
Unless the comparison is Marvin vs. Rice, The answer is Marvin.
Marvin all day. Top 10 WR of all time, wouldnt out reggie anywhere before the top 50
88 is my guy!
Reggie is one of my favorite, if not favorite colt ever but you gotta go with marvin. he’s was an extremely rare and elite talent at the position.
still absolutely love reggie wayne from stately wayne manor
Dallas Tyreggison.