Who had the more dominant NFCCG performance: Plaxico Burress against Al Harris or Victor Cruz against Carlos Rogers?
December 17, 2024
Who had the more dominant NFCCG performance: Plaxico Burress against Al Harris or Victor Cruz against Carlos Rogers?
24 comments
I mean, Roger’s was on the sideline begging for help basically. He got cooked that game
Plax
Plax. Easy. Eli is the nod for the niners game. Wouldn’t stay down like they thought he would.
Plax embarrassed Harris. No question in my mind which was more dominant lol
Plax really carried that game. Eli was coming into his own at that point.
Eli is the reason why we won in San Fran. He single handed willed his way to victory. Cruz absolutely dominated but 2nd half didn’t have a catch if I remember correctly.
Plax. To have that game in -23 degree weather is absurd
Both were so good.
It’s a tie imo.
Plax was legendary when dude locked in no one could stop him.
Plaxico gets my vote. Freezing cold weather in Green Bay and he dominated
Crazy that these CBs were both All-pro/Pro-bowl guys at the time of these games too.
Plax because of the conditions
Plaxico. Dude did it with one leg and in the tundra
Plax easily. In those conditions on top of how dominate he was that game… hard to beat.
Ahhhhh remember when we were good?
It doesn’t matter they were both great. And much better than Beckham ever did for us. Hopefully Nabors delivers when it counts. And hopefully he gets chances.
Cruz finished off Harris by halftime with which felt like a million receptions.
Both were epic, but burress was hurt so I give him the edge… I know it wasn’t an nfccg, but nicks was a monster the week before in GB as well
Close but I’ll give it to Plax due to the weather conditions while cooking Harris
Plax by a fairly wide margin. 11/151 in 0 degree weather while playing on a bum ankle and not practicing during the week was so so baller. Al Harris was also one of the top CBs that season and Plax just bullied him all day. Cruz had a nice game in 2011 and frustrated Rodgers but he didn’t dominate the way Plax did against better competition.
Nicks against Green Bay.
Plax
Gotta be Cruz lol. That was a ridiculous game.
I miss this era of football even independent of the Giants. Felt like every game was massive. Probably just nostalgia.
Al Harris was a top CB at the time.
He looked like boy trying to stop a full grown man that day…
24 comments
I mean, Roger’s was on the sideline begging for help basically. He got cooked that game
Plax
Plax. Easy. Eli is the nod for the niners game. Wouldn’t stay down like they thought he would.
Plax embarrassed Harris. No question in my mind which was more dominant lol
Plax really carried that game. Eli was coming into his own at that point.
Eli is the reason why we won in San Fran. He single handed willed his way to victory. Cruz absolutely dominated but 2nd half didn’t have a catch if I remember correctly.
Plax. To have that game in -23 degree weather is absurd
Both were so good.
It’s a tie imo.
Plax was legendary when dude locked in no one could stop him.
Plaxico gets my vote. Freezing cold weather in Green Bay and he dominated
Crazy that these CBs were both All-pro/Pro-bowl guys at the time of these games too.
Plax because of the conditions
Plaxico. Dude did it with one leg and in the tundra
Plax easily. In those conditions on top of how dominate he was that game… hard to beat.
Ahhhhh remember when we were good?
It doesn’t matter they were both great. And much better than Beckham ever did for us. Hopefully Nabors delivers when it counts. And hopefully he gets chances.
Cruz finished off Harris by halftime with which felt like a million receptions.
Both were epic, but burress was hurt so I give him the edge… I know it wasn’t an nfccg, but nicks was a monster the week before in GB as well
Close but I’ll give it to Plax due to the weather conditions while cooking Harris
Plax by a fairly wide margin. 11/151 in 0 degree weather while playing on a bum ankle and not practicing during the week was so so baller. Al Harris was also one of the top CBs that season and Plax just bullied him all day. Cruz had a nice game in 2011 and frustrated Rodgers but he didn’t dominate the way Plax did against better competition.
Nicks against Green Bay.
Plax
Gotta be Cruz lol. That was a ridiculous game.
I miss this era of football even independent of the Giants. Felt like every game was massive. Probably just nostalgia.
Al Harris was a top CB at the time.
He looked like boy trying to stop a full grown man that day…
Plax abused Harris